The days of golf in Madison County might be numbered.
Sunrise Golf Course owner John Byram says he’ll close the county’s only course if his application for a rezone is denied this month.
Byram once again will present plans to county leaders to transform the financially troubled Colbert course into an active retirement development with a mostly par-3 set up. Byram’s proposal is on the agenda for the planning and zoning commission’s Jan. 20 meeting. He’ll present the project to the board of commissioners Jan. 26.
These plans are identical to the ones the county board of commissioners rejected in February of last year.
“The golf course is something I want to keep,” Byram said. “The only way to keep the golf course is allowing an active retirement community be built around it. There’s no way I can keep throwing money at it. I’m running out.”
Byram’s plans call for 158 single-family homes and 60 townhouses. Alterations to the golf course would leave Sunrise with three par-four’s and 15 par three’s.
Byram noted that some of the par threes would be over 200 yards long from the back tees.
“It’s not going to be like a pitch-and-putt, it’s going to be a sure-enough executive-level course.”
The retirement community would be restricted to those 55-and-older, but the course would still be open to the public.
“It’s not going to be just a retirement community golf course,” he said. “It will still be open to the public … There’s a lot of advantages to keep it as a golf course.”
If the project is approved, the land will always stay as either a golf course or green space.
“It cannot be further developed,” Byram said.
Byram bought the course in 2002, but said it’s been nothing but a financial burden ever since.
“I’ve been losing money every year on it,” Byram said. “It’s been a long row to hoe.”
Altering Sunrise and incorporating it into an active adult retirement community is the only way he sees that the golf course can survive in any capacity. Byram said there’s a “pent-up” demand for this and feels this is one of few projects in which developers would feel comfortable given the current plight of the housing market.
With 200 residents, he said there’s a good chance the course in this new incarnation would be successful.
“There are no other retirement communities in North Georgia on a golf course. None,” Byram said. “This would be the first of its kind.”
If approved, Byram said there are those who might buy the project from him. But another denial by BOC means Sunrise’s days are over, he said.
“I’m going to close the golf course immediately,” Byram said. “I’m not going to keep it open more than a few days if I get turned down.”
Then, he says he’ll sell the land off in chunks.
Byram says he has little choice.
Given the tough economic climate, luxury items like golf are usually the first to go. In a word, Byram described business in 2008 as “terrible” for Sunrise.
“It was maybe two-thirds the play that it was the previous year,” he said.
Byram also noted that Jennings’ Mill’s Golf Course was recently hit with foreclosure.
But there is a niche, he said, to be served in retirement communities in North Georgia. Byram explained that Florida, a hotbed for retirees, is not being developed like it used to.
What’s more, he hopes this appeals to University of Georgia alumni as a second-home community.
“That’s a still very active group of retirees that have money,” he said.
Byram said he can’t afford to continue losing his own money each month.
He tried to rezone the course back in 2003 as a regular subdivision, but was denied by the BOC.
The retirement community is the only other option, Byram said.
“It’s the only thing that I can do with it other than shut it down and sell 10-15 acre lots for cows,” he said.
That is an excellent idea. No rezone will be necessary, no extra burden will be put on our already strained water and services, and the land will be in fitting with Madison County agriculture.
Buying the golf course was a risk Byram took. It is fairly obvious a rezone was his intention all along. His disingenuous lack of forthcoming is reason enough to deny the rezone again. It failed because it was not a well maintained, attractive golf course. It's location was horrible from day one. Now there is competition that is better and maintained better as well.
Mr. Byram has solved his own problem: 10-15 acre lots for cows. His words, not mine, not the commissioners. I don't even think he needs a rezone for the pasture use. Why is he even bothering the commissioners with this again?
Building non-sustainable developments and further saturating a completely dead, depressed housing market only further depresses the market by contributing even more to an already overabundant, over built market which only hurts carpenters and the hardware store much more.
Look ahead, think long term. Short term thinking like you are espousing is what got us into this mess to begin with.
No one wants to play a par 3 course, and it will lose money. Mark my words, if the rezoning is passed, shortly after the completion of his retirement community he will go back on his word and ask to develop the rest of the land.
I'm affraid either way we are going to lose our golf course, and that is a shame.
several months ago due to the neglect and consequential
detoriation of the facilities. I think Byrum bought this
course after forclosure or near-forclosure with the
intention of dividing it up into lots or a subdivision but
the planning commission and board of commissioners have
turned him down time and time again. He has done nothing
to promote play on the course and the greens fees are
much too high for a course of this quality. I hate to see
it close but in these economic times, I see little choice
THESE PEOPLE MOVING TO THIS DEVELOPMENT.
SEEING AS HOW THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND SCHOOL
SYSTEM BUYS A LOT OF THEIR SUPPLIES AND SERVICES
FROM OUTSIDE THE COUNTY THIS COULD BE A POSTIVE
FOR LOCAL MERCHANTS.
And, in response to "Wake Up People!'s" comment about no one wanting to play executive length courses - you are mistaken. People do play them - I actually prefer them. The Charlie Yates Course in Atlanta is an executive length course and is ALWAYS busy. Executive courses are much more time-friendly and would allow people to play in the afternoons after work.
Agriculture is very important and is a vital part of our county, but let's take a chance on economic improvement for our county.
“In northeast Georgia we’re not in a housing recession, we’re in a housing depression,” Jim Williams, president of Southern Highlands Mortgage in Blairsville, told state lawmakers at a daylong hearing Wednesday. “The retiree market, the secondary market has all but dried up."
There you have it. There is no retiree market in Northeast GA, not to mention Madison County. So, what happens if this is approved (doubt it) and they build a bunch of houses, or condos, or apartments and the retirees aren't moving in as reflected in the testimony above? Riiiiiiiiiiight...it's just a less than forthright developer's attempt to manipulate the rules, the law, the commissioners and the taxpayers of this county. Not only should he not get this rezone, but as a penalty for his dishonesty he should be prevented from bringing ANY rezones for ANY projects before the BOC for a minimum of 2 years. Shady developers like this give the honest legitimate builders a bad name.
Planning ahead suggests foresight. Planning for such community shows at least thinking of future.
He is saying, rezone my property. The golf course doesn't work (even though it's not properly maintainged). I'm not building random housing. It's only for retirees.
Guess what? What happens if retirees don't come? Will he enforce the 55 and up rule and leave the houses vacant for as many years as it takes until they show up? Or, will he do what he has done with the "golf course" idea...come back to the BOC and say, "This retiree idea isn't working out...just like the golf course didn't work...I need ANOTHER exception made for poor me."
Yes, that's manipulative at the least. My grandpa called it "shady."
When some developer like this one goofs and makes a bad decision and things don't go his way, suddenly it's time to make exceptions and turn to the good, honest folk who aren't trying to rape every square inch of earth for $$$ and tell them he needs a BAILOUT.
When are we going to say enough is enough?
A friend of mine is VP at a local bank. I asked him if there was any way "retirees" (this thing says 55 and up...most people don't retire until at least age 65!) would move into a development like this, in Colbert, around a "golf course" that looks like a cow pasture. He literally laughed loud and rather long and said, "Only in their imagination! Banks are foreclosing left and right. It's like Byram is the Pied Piper and your commissioners the children. He plays the flute, and your commissioners dance."